Iced Oatmeal Cut Out Cookies

Imagine biting into the most delicious oatmeal cookie! Now you can make them in any shape you like with this great cut out oatmeal cookie recipe and top them with icing too. These are a great addition to a holiday cookie platter, for sharing with friends over a cup of coffee and a nice long chat or to snack on at midnight, you choose!   
Iced Oatmeal Cut Out Cookies @createdbydiane

Oatmeal Cookies get a NEW LOOK!

 I worked on an oatmeal cookie recipe that would end up chewy and delicious, but not dry. I wasn’t sure I would be able to roll out and cut oatmeal with a cookie cutter, but as you can see the edges of the cookie aren’t that jagged.

They have that nice unpolished homemade look and I love them, almost as much as I love my new blog design.

I couldn’t decide if I wanted the icing bright white or cinnamon, so I made both. It reminded me of deciding on a new blog look, decisions, decisions.

I was so happy to make an oatmeal cookie that I could cut out. I thought the oats would be hard to work with a cookie cutter.

I decided to chop the oats with a knife, I didn’t want to put them in a food processor and lose all texture.  I ran the knife over them about ten times. The chopped oats are on the left. I put regular oats on the right for you to see the difference. Sometimes it’s the little things that make projects easier, this is one of those times.

This dough is sticky so be sure to flour your surface well, along with your rolling pin and cookie cutter.

 

 

I outlined some cookies for the crazy people who don’t like a lot of icing.

 

There are two printable recipes below, one for the Oatmeal Cut Out Cookie and Another for the icing recipes.

 

Print Recipe
4.67 from 6 votes

Iced Oatmeal Cut Out Cookies

Chewy Oatmeal Cut Out Cookies with Icing
Author: Diane createdby-diane.com

Ingredients

  • 1 cup butter
  • 1 cup brown sugar
  • 1 egg
  • 1 1/2 cups flour
  • 2 teaspoons vanilla extract
  • 1 teaspoon cinnamon
  • 2 teaspoons baking powder
  • 1 1/2 cups Old Fashioned Quaker Oats cut up with knife

Instructions

  • Beat butter and sugar.
  • Add in the egg and mix thoroughly.
  • Add flour, vanilla, cinnamon, baking powder, and oats to the mixture.
  • Mix well.
  • Roll out dough on a well-floured surface with a floured rolling pin.
  • Cut with a floured cookie cutter.
  • Place on parchment-lined cookie sheet and bake at 350 degrees.
  • For 7-9 minutes until just golden.
  • Makes 4 dozen cookies

 

 

Iced Oatmeal Cut Out Cookies
 
Recipe Type: dessert, icing, frosting, sugar
Cuisine: American
Author: Diane Schmidt Created by Diane
Prep time:
Total time:
Serves: 1 cup
An easy sugar icing to decorate cakes, cookies and other sweet treats with.
Ingredients
  • White Icing
  • 1 cup powdered sugar
  • 1 teaspoon corn syrup
  • 1 teaspoon vanilla
  • 2 teaspoons water
  • add a drop of white food coloring for extra white opague icing
  • Cinnamon Icing
  • 1 cup powdered sugar
  • 1 teaspoon corn syrup
  • Β½ teaspoon cinnamon
  • 5 drops cinnamon extract
  • 2 teaspoons water
Instructions
  1. Mix sugar, syrup, flavorings and water along with food coloring until creamy. Add a drop at a time more water if needed until you get a smooth consistency.
  2. Pipe icing on cookies with a piping bag with a #4 Tip and fill in the icing so the cookies look smooth.

 

 

 

 

the BEST Cookie Advice and Tips to make delicious cookies www.createdbydiane.com

 

oatmeal cut out cookies @createdbydiane www.createdby-diane.com

84 Comments

  1. I absolutely love your new blog design. So clean and fresh!!! The oatmeal cookies look awesome too…I never thought about cutting out oatmeal ones!!!

    1. These cookies were a disaster. Too wet to roll out!!! What did I do wrong?

    2. The only “wet” ingredients are butter and vanilla, be sure your butter is not soft, but cool and at room temperature. If it’s overly hot in your kitchen it can make the butter soft which could possibly make the cookie dough sticky, just add a tablespoon of flour at a time until the cookie dough is manageable for you to roll out. Flour the surface you will roll the dough on, flour the rolling pin as well. That should help you to be able to roll it out.

  2. 5 stars
    The redesign looks AMAZING, almost as good as those cookies!! They look absolutely scrumptious, can’t wait to try them out with some cute designs. Another winner Diane! πŸ™‚

    1. yea, the cinnamon icing is a FAVORITE around here, can’t wait to put it on more items. I put it on oatmeal raisin cookies and cinnamon raisin scones too πŸ™‚
      Glad you like the new look, I do too. The recipe index was finished today πŸ™‚

  3. These look so delicious, I’ve been making cut out oatmeal cookies for several years, and I love them well then again I love cookies so …
    Love love the new blog!!!

    1. I so wish I had made them sooner πŸ™‚
      thanks, I’m loving the new look too. Just had the recipe index finished today πŸ™‚

  4. I just found your blog and everything looks so yummmy and perfect. I am now your newest follower and will be checking back often. Jalon
    PS – I posted your adorable Cotton-tail Cupcakes picture with a link back to your blog on my blog’s sidebar for my readers’ Easter reference!
    Enjoy your day.

    1. I’m so glad you like everything πŸ™‚ I love all those outdoor photos you have, we are just finishing up making out outdoor are look more comfortable with curtains and such.
      Thanks for posting my cupcake, I can’t believe it’s almost Easter!

  5. iced oatmeal are one of my favorite cookies – I will be trying these! I love americolor white!

    looks like you frosted your whole site in americolor white – so crisp and fresh – I love it!

  6. First off the these are one of my favorite childhood cookies. And secondly, sorry I”ve been so behind on my blog reading-your blog facelift looks AWESOME!!!!

  7. Pingback: baking barefoot: iced oatmeal cut out cookies « thebarefootmarket
  8. These are incredibly cute, and I love that they are oatmeal. Eating oatmeal cookies makes me feel a little less guilty when I’m devouring them instead of a heavy chocolate chunk peanut butter one πŸ™‚

    Also, loving the new blog design. Looks gorgeous.

  9. Finally catching up with blog reading and land here…on your beautiful new crisp and clean new site. I love it Diane πŸ™‚

    I also love the sound of these oatmeal cut-out cookies. Going to try these for certain and that cinnamon icing sounds delicious…perfect for the oatmeal cookies πŸ™‚

  10. I’m planning to make these for my daughter’s birthday party! Can I make them 2-3 days ahead and how should I store them? Also, can I color the icing or add sanding sugar while it’s still wet? Thanks a bunch, they look delicious!

    1. Yes, you can make them days ahead. Allow icing to dry completely before storing in airtight container. 24 hrs. They won’t go stale, the icing keeps them fresh. Yes you can color the icing, the white, is with white coloring to make it extra bright, any color would be pretty. As far as sanding sugar, yes of course you can add it when icing is still wet. Happy Baking!

  11. I am looking at your wonderful recipe and I am wondering if the ratio of butter to dry ingredients is too high — are you sure that it is 1 cup (1 stick/8 ounces) of butter in the recipe? Your website is beautiful and so are these cookies!

    1. I use salted butter as I prefer the taste not to be so sweet, so if you use unsalted butter you could add 1/2 teaspoon salt to the recipe to balance the sweetness. I’ve made these many times since posting and have added some salt even with the salted butter πŸ™‚

  12. 4 stars
    My 4 year old son loves to bake with me but I get tired of making messy, unhealthy sugar cookies. These are awesome. I used whole wheat flour and they look delish! 2 mins until they’re out of the oven and we will know for sure. Thanks!

  13. These cookies sound fantastic. I wanted to warn you though that you spelled the word lose as loose when you wrote about not wanting to lose the texture of the oats.

  14. I am looking for a very crisp oatmeal/ multigrain cutout that maybe I can add chopped dried blueberries. Do you think this will work?

  15. 5 stars
    wow,thanks for the recipe πŸ™‚ these cookies came out amazing! just substituted 1\2 cup flour with the same amount of processed oats and dipped the cookies in dark chocolate :))) barely managed to hide them :))

  16. Hi! I am so excited to find your recipes for cut-out cookies. I love that type of cookie but wanted to find different flavors. They are hard to find and I do not have a huge amount of time to tweak the recipes that I have. I am excited to try some soon – I have a birthday for a toddler coming up and no one likes cake as much as I think they do so I thought I would make cookies.

    1. I’m so glad you found what you needed. I love different flavored cut out cookies, there is always a new one coming πŸ™‚

  17. Hi! Just made these for my daughter’s Valentine’s Day party that will be held on Friday (today is Tuesday). Do you recommend I freeze them to keep them fresh? Do you think I should just keep them at room temp in an air tight container until Friday?

    PS- They are great! My daughter already ate 2 and is begging for more!

    1. They will still be fresh if kept in an airtight container for the three days.Happy Valentines Day! ALternatively, you can wrap them in food type party bags individually if you don’t want them to become softer and hold their firmness. Softer cookies tend to get a little softer the longer they are stored in a container with a whole batch of cookies after a couple days. For parties I wrap individually if I want them to not soften.

    2. I didn’t mention if you iced the cookies be sure not to put them in a container for 24 hours or the moisture in the icing will soften the cookie and won’t dry firm or set up.

  18. I just made these and added some shaved dark chocolate to the recipe to give them just a touch of that flavor I love so much. It worked great! My only problem was I think I accidentally added too much flour while rolling out the dough, so they ended up being a little crunchier than probably intended. I’ll keep that in mind next time! Let’s hope my attempt at the icing tomorrow morning will go well. Thank you for the lovely, delicious recipe!

  19. I was very excited to try these but the dough was a disaster…it was like basically spreading peanut butter onto my countertops. My butter was room temperature and I put TONS of flour on my counter top, on top of the dough, on my rolling pin, on the cookie cutters. I was skeptic bc the dough was so incredibly soft and sticky but I decided to trust the recipe and use flour everything up and roll out the dough. It was a horrible mess. Either this recipe needs more flour or you MUST chill it before attempting to roll it out. I scraped up the disgusting mess and put it in a bowl in the fridge. At this point, I will not re-attempt to roll out the dough but will try spooning the chilled dough onto a cookie sheet and baking it. Very disappointed. I bought cute Fall cookie cutters specifically for this recipe. If I wanted a regular oatmeal cookie recipe, I would have used my tried & true recipe instead of this one.

    1. Sorry to hear you had trouble with the dough. Yes, it is sticky, you can roll it in between wax paper if you don’t prefer adding more flour, and yes you can chill it. If your kitchen is warm it will make the dough harder to roll. Since I’m not there will you I can’t troubleshoot any better than that at this point. But as you can see by the photos the recipe does work, the cookies hold their shape even if they need a little more attention than a traditional sugar cookie.

    2. I had the same problem. After chilling I tried the wax paper and got it to roll but couldn’t get any cookies up off the counter after cutting them out.

      It’s back in the fridge.

      Any other suggestions? Should I add more flour to the dough?

    3. Yes, you can add as much flour as you need to be able to handle them, you can also lightly flour wax paper to roll it out. Flour the spatula you’re lifting them up with also.

  20. Hi! First, I’m not a baker, therefore I guess I did something really dumb…. melting rock hard butter in the microwave.

    When the dough was too sticky to roll out I put it in the fridge to chill, thinking this would help.

    It was still a total disaster. My 2 1/2 year old and I were making this for Valentine’s Day and the look of disappointment on his face was just devastating.

    Any suggestions on how to fix overly sticky dough?

    1. Hello, I saw your second message first.
      So let’s start with butter, it should be at room temperature for 30 minutes for baking. If you don’t normally bake there are easier recipes than tackling a recipe that is not as basic as a sugar cookie. My sugar cookie recipe https://www.createdby-diane.com/2011/07/sugar-cookie-recipe.html it does not spread is not sticky and is pretty fool-proof as you I have dumped all ingredients into a mixer bowl and was able to mix and roll and cut and the cookies still came out great without following any directions. when making cut out cookies adding flour will dry out the dough, so add accordingly if you’re having trouble with it being sticky, but if you melted the butter, even refrigerating the dough will not often help melted butter as the butter has completely changed, (butter separates when heated)
      Second, try starting with a drop sugar cookie recipe that you don’t need to cut into shapes is easier like these https://www.createdby-diane.com/2017/05/soft-sugar-cookies.html
      I have a whole list of drop cookies all different flavors including oatmeal https://www.createdby-diane.com/2017/12/drop-cookies.html
      I’m happy to help answer any questions you may have. I’d love for you to be able to master cut out cookies, I have lots of posts on cookies including cut out cookies here https://www.createdby-diane.com/2017/09/how-to-bake-perfect-cut-out-cookies.html
      and lots of info on cookie tips here https://www.createdby-diane.com/cookie-tips

    1. Hi! We made it using quick cooking oats. It was wet probably because it’s hot here in the Philippines. We added 1/2cup flour and 1/2 cup oats and it was rollable and cutable. πŸ™‚ Came out great! Thanks for sharing your great recipe!

  21. Hi, just another question. How long will these cookies last in room temp? Should I put them in the refrigerator? Thank you so much for answering! πŸ™‚

    1. These cookies can be baked one day, ices the next, then allow the icing to dry for 12 hours, they can then stay at room temperature for a week in a container or wrapped individually, you can refrigerate or freeze them as well. You can bake and ice on the same day but be sure they are completely cooled. Once the cookies are iced they hold the moisture in the cookie and don’t get dry or harden as they would if not iced. They will last in a cookie jar as well for a week. As you can see a great cookie, and storing them is very flexible to what you need.

    1. If you’re using it in the icing, just add a couple drops, it’s not a huge batch. If you are replacing cinnamon in the recipe use a smaller amount that the cinnamon called for as maple extract is strong.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating