Looks like a PUMPKIN SHAKE,
TASTES like a PUMPKIN SHAKE,
but it’s a
FAUX PUMPKIN SHAKE!
You read it right, it’s a FAKE!
A fake shake, actually!
It tastes delicious,
cold and creamy,
just like a pumpkin pie.
But it’s fake….
it’s not made with pumpkin,
it’s not made with cream,
it’s not made with ice cream
but,
it sure does taste great!
Faux Pumpkin Shake Recipe
1/2 cup fat free milk
1/2 cup fat free plain yogurt (I use Fage fat free Greek yogurt)
1 cooked yam
1/2 tsp. pumpkin pie spice, plus enough shake on top.
mix in a blender and serve.
If you like this or any other recipe at 
Jacqueline says
I have never had a pumpkin shake, so I cannot compare, but this looks lush. Mmmmmmm 😛
Headmistress, zookeeper says
Well, I think fat is really good for you, so I'd make it with whole milk and whole milk yogurt – but what catches my attention is no sweetening. Really? THAT would be seriously healthy. I have to try this!
Sue says
I'm going to try this, but with pumpkin:)
cookies and cups says
This looks great! WHat made you use yams instead of pumpkin?
Colleen (Shibley Smiles) says
You blog is making me fat just visiting it!
Visiting from Free Hot Samples. Following you now Would love for you to stop by.
Colleen
Shibley Smiles
bridget {bake at 350} says
Aren't you SMART?!? And I LOVE Fage yogurt…mmmm.
Raina says
This sounds great! I love the flavor of pumpkin spices but not a fan of actually eating pumpkin for some strange reason..lol So I would really love your shake. Thanks")
Headmistress, zookeeper says
I made it, and it was DEEEElicious! I think the sweet potato makes it taste more like pumpkin than pumpkin would taste, oddly enough.
I also think this would be seriously delicious mixed with softened cream cheese and then poured in a pie shell and chilled as a pumpkin cheesecake dessert.
Thanks so much!
jilmac says
Mmmm, I'm going to have to try this shake! After reading the other comments I can't wait.